This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.
BLACK FRIDAY SALE -  GET 25% OFF TODAY!

BLACK FRIDAY SALE - GET 25% OFF

The Happy Valentine's Day Box - Nettie's Bakery

Peppermint and Marshmallow Brownie Cake


25% OFF BLACK FRIDAY  SALE - Coupon Code BLACKFRIDAY has been automatically applied!

$36.99

Verified Review

Best brownies I have ever had! So chocolatey! Perfectly rich and the perfect level of sweet. This is going to be my go-to gift from now on. 
- Nicole in Georgia

QuantityOne Giant Brownie
In Stock · Ships Fast
Order Now, Schedule Shipping for Later
EMPTY DOM REMOVE PROTECTOR
Flat Rate Nationwide Shipping
Fast Delivery In Just 2-3 Days
Order Now, Schedule Shipping For Later
Love Your Product Guarantee We put our best into everything we bake and are confident that it shows. If you don't love your first box, we'll give your money back.

Over One Pound!! We took our fan-favorite peppermint brownie, topped it with homemade marshmallows, and made the perfect winter treat!

Because sometimes you need something a little extra to bring people together.

Our Peppermint and Marshmallow Brownie is handcrafted from the bottom up:
✔️ Fudgy peppermint brownie base
✔️ Real handmade vanilla marshmallows
✔️ All wrapped in milk chocolate
✔️ Topped with crushed peppermint

It’s the treat you bring to a holiday gathering and suddenly become everyone’s favorite guest. Or the gift you send that doesn’t even need a card.

🔥 Super limited release. 100% crave-worthy.

We ship orders Monday through Thursday via UPS Ground or FedEx 2-Day shipping. Most orders arrive in two days or less.

You may schedule your desired shipping date at checkout and your order will leave our bakery on that day.

Read more about shipping here.


[{"variant_id":"47544398643454" , "metafield_value":""},{"variant_id":"47544398676222" , "metafield_value":""},{"variant_id":"47544398708990" , "metafield_value":""}]

Peppermint and Marshmallow Brownie Cake

$36.99
  • 5 stars: 673 (83%)
  • 4 stars: 73 (9%)
  • 3 stars: 45 (6%)
  • 2 stars: 13 (2%)
  • 1 star: 6 (1%)
Some of the reviews shown are from related products the merchant grouped with this one.
C
Cathy
Congrats Gift Box

The recipient was so happy and enjoyed the sweet treats. I ordered another Pick Your Flavors 30-Piece Box and sent them to my daughter in California.

J
Joan Tenny
Mint brownies

Nettie‘s mint brownies are absolutely fabulous❣️

K
Kat B.
Sheer Heaven

I am very fussy when it comes to chocolate and brownies. These little bites combine the best of both. Quite decadent and goes a long way… having said that, I’m a little embarrassed to say they’re almost gone!

K
Kristina Kouris
Literally my favorite thing

I’m about to place my third order. I’m obsessed with the brownie marshmallow combo!! First it was s’mores now the peppermint AHHHHHH!!! ITS LITERALLY ONE OF THE BEST THINGS IVE EVER HAD!!!! Buy & you won’t regret!!

P
Pam Bartkus

Great temperature control during shipping! Didn’t have to worry at all about spoilage!

A
Annette Guerne
My order was Amazing 6/26/25 from LI to SC Baked goodies form Center Moriches to low country of SC

To all @ Netties Bakery,Moving here to SC one of the Best things was finding out your goodies such as the variety of brownie bites, and the s’mores brownies were the first item delivered here and it felt like I was back home, enjoying our Netties goodies so excited I can get your bakery goodies delivered a few hundred miles away!! Here’s to being long distances customers-until each visit back to Longisland N.Y. Yours Truly, Annette (Nettie) Guerne,always a New Yorker and a SC girl

J
Jerrica B.
Very good

I was hesitant at first about having brownies shipped but omgoshhh these were perfect. I say were because they barely lasted a day in our home. Will definitely be ordering again.

L
Linda Vandenburg
I expected better at the price.

I’m sorry to say so, but I was very disappointed. I did not care for the coating. and the actual brownie part itself was terrible.

A
Anonymous
Convenient, reliable, and delicious

I ordered an assortment of 60 brownies to have instead of a birthday cake for a large party. They arrived on time, tasted delicious and fresh and I received nothing but rave reviews. Will definitely be ordering again.

S
Susan Aue-Schneider
Wonderful

Netties never disappoints! Product came in perfect condition, packaged accordingly for chocolates. The flavors are like a party in your mouth and I like the option to pick your own box of preferred flavors.

K
Kim Fanelli
Classic rainbow cookies

The inside cake was simply delicious and the chocolate outside was very thick. Too much chocolate on the cookies.

J
Jesse Williams
Nettie backery

It was better than expected will order again

H
Howard Osofsky
Over the Rsinbow

I've enjoyed Rainbow Cookiies for over 50 years. From prestigious bakeries, deli's, diner's, homemade kitchens, etc. Nettie's Classic Rainbow Cookies are the best I've ever had. Meticulous detail in production and fast are also unparalleled. These are not just cookies....they are delicious desserts and truly "over the rainbow." Veru generous portions too, which is rare in this category. I'm.a new customer.

E
Elizabeth

I was very satisfied with my order. It took a little long to get here, but I’m glad that it came.

L
Linda S Hayes
Best birthday gift

Our good friend recently received the Cake Combo for her birthday and she could say enough about how much she enjoyed them.
On our part we are very satisfied with the ordering and prompt delivery. Thank you

A
Arline OReilly
MMMM..Good

very tasty and well presented. I froze half for another time and they came out great

W
William Healy
Brownies

The brownies themselves are excellent. I don’t think the candy topping helps your product.

A
Ariel R
Great

Package arrived on time and in good condition. I sampled a lot of different brownie flavors but really enjoyed the pumpkin spice one the most! Ate all 15 brownies 🤰

M
MaribelM
Love LOVE THE KEY LIME BITES !!!!

I ordered for in-laws and they LOVED THEM!!

M
Mason Stripp

Rich and smooth

I
Ingrid Skidmore
Rainbow cookies

I sent a box of rainbow cookies to my son in the army. They arrived in great condition and fresh. He can’t stop raving about them.

A
Arol Magee
Reese Review

My purchase was a huge hit. They thought it was very tasty and very rich. I would order again for someone special.

M
Marcal
Best Brownies Ever!

My son said the brownies were the “best ever.” They were fudgy & delicious and he loved the assortment! Would definitely buy them again!

E
Ellen Whitaker
Heavenly Brownies

These are my third order of brownies. They are all delicious. I have to control myself to eat only one a day.

J
Joany O
Halloween gift

Recipient enjoying the gift. Great product.

S
Susan Avren
Delicious cakes!

Ordered for my friend that hurt her arm and accidentally sent it to my home.
The cakes were so good, I will confidently reorder correctly.
What a delicious mistake I made!

K
Karen Brownlow

So yummy

R
Rebecca Higgins
Love them

We loved them. I love that you can create your own box with so many options.

P
Patsy Hall

Sent to NYU
My granddaughter loves it

J
JEANNE GARDNER
OMG! It Doesn't Get Any Better...

The first bite of this S'mores Marshmallow Brownie Cake does not disappoint! It looked so big that I cut it into 6 pieces to share with my husband. The marshmallow is great by itself, but put together with a decadent brownie, chocolate coating and graham cracker crust and you have the best thing I've ever eaten!! Keep them coming!

As seen in

Frequently Asked Questions

Where Are Your Products Made?

We make all of our products at our family bakery In Center Moriches, NY. We have been serving our local community from our retail location for over 10 years!

Will This Make A Good Gift?

What's a better gift than delicious treats? We guarantee these will arrive quickly and in great condition. Every product is packaged in our specialty gift box for a special and unique surprise.

How does shipping work?

We ship orders Monday through Thursday via FedEx 2-Day or UPS 1-2 Day Ground. You can choose your shipping day at checkout and we'll make sure your orders leaves the bakery that day. Learn more here.

I have another question.

We're happy to help with any questions you might have. Please use our contact for here or email us at info@nettiesbakery.com.

-->